It Ends with Us vs Verity: Which to Read First?
Same author, completely different experience. One is an emotional contemporary romance about a hard subject; the other is a dark, twisty thriller. Here's how to choose.
By Lena Fischer
Colleen Hoover is one of the best-selling authors in the world, and the two books most often recommended as a starting point — It Ends with Us and Verity — could hardly be more different. This trips up a lot of new readers, who assume that “a Colleen Hoover book” is a single kind of thing. It is not. Choosing between these two is really choosing between two completely different reading experiences that happen to share an author.
The honest distinction
It Ends with Us is an emotional contemporary romance that turns, partway through, into something heavier: a serious and personal exploration of domestic abuse, drawn from Hoover’s own family history. It is the book that made her a phenomenon. It is romantic, it is painful, and it builds to a decision that has stayed with millions of readers. If someone tells you a Colleen Hoover book made them sob, this is usually the one.
Verity is a dark romantic thriller — a struggling writer is hired to finish the work of an incapacitated bestselling author and discovers a hidden manuscript that may be a confession. It is twisty, genuinely disturbing, and built around an ending so ambiguous that readers still argue about what actually happened. The romance is present but secondary to the suspense and the dread.
So the choice is not “which is better” but “what do you want tonight.”
A quick way to decide
| If you want… | Read |
|---|---|
| An emotional, romance-led story that tackles a real and difficult subject | It Ends with Us |
| A dark, twisty, page-turning thriller with a shocking ending | Verity |
| The book everyone is talking about / the cultural touchstone | It Ends with Us |
| Suspense and dread over romance and feelings | Verity |
A necessary word on content
Both books deal with heavy material and both deserve a content check before you begin. It Ends with Us centres on domestic abuse and depicts it directly. Verity contains disturbing themes, violence, and explicit content. These are not gentle comfort reads, and going in informed makes for a better experience.
Which should you read first?
For most readers new to Colleen Hoover, start with It Ends with Us — it is the definitive Hoover experience, the one that explains why she became a phenomenon, and the better introduction to what she does best. Come to Verity second, when you want something darker and faster and are in the mood to be unsettled rather than moved.
What each actually delivers
It Ends with Us is built to make you feel. It moves through a hopeful early romance into a wrenching central conflict, and its power comes from how completely you come to care about its heroine before the hardest part of the story arrives. The much-discussed decision at its climax is what lingers — and what made it the book friends press on friends. It also has a direct sequel, It Starts with Us, if you want to keep going.
Verity is built to unsettle. It withholds, misleads, and steadily ratchets up the dread, and its genius is an ending that refuses to resolve — readers finish it and immediately go looking for someone else who has read it, just to argue about what was real. It is shorter, faster, and far less interested in your heart than in your nerves.
Knowing which of those experiences you actually want is the whole game.
Read next
If It Ends with Us was the emotional pull, Reminders of Him is the natural next Hoover read. If Verity hooked you, move into pure psychological-thriller territory with The Silent Patient and Behind Closed Doors. For more, see our guides to books like It Ends with Us and books like Verity.
Affiliate disclosure: Links on this page are affiliate links. We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I read It Ends with Us or Verity first?
It depends entirely on what you want, because they are not alike. Read It Ends with Us first if you want the emotional, romance-driven Colleen Hoover experience that made her a phenomenon — it is her most beloved and most discussed book. Read Verity first if you would rather skip the romance and go straight to a dark, twisty thriller. They are standalone novels with no connection, so order is purely a matter of mood.
Which is darker, It Ends with Us or Verity?
Verity is darker in tone and content — it is a disturbing psychological thriller with genuinely unsettling material and a famously divisive ending. It Ends with Us deals with a heavy and serious subject (domestic abuse) but does so within an emotional, hopeful romance framework. Verity is designed to disturb; It Ends with Us is designed to move you. Both carry content warnings worth checking before you start.
Are It Ends with Us and Verity connected?
No. They are completely separate standalone novels with different characters, settings, and genres. It Ends with Us has a sequel, It Starts with Us, but Verity stands entirely alone. You can read them in any order or read only one.
Which Colleen Hoover book is the most popular?
It Ends with Us is her best-known and best-selling novel, propelled to enormous popularity by word of mouth on social media and later a film adaptation. Verity is her most popular thriller and a favourite among readers who prefer suspense to romance. Between them they are the two books most likely to be recommended as a starting point for Hoover.
