Apprentice to the Villain — Assistant and the Villain, Book Two

A Warmer, Riskier Second Act

Apprentice to the Villain picks up where Hannah Nicole Maehrer’s viral, TikTok-born debut left off, and it does what a good second book in a cozy series should: it deepens the relationships and raises the stakes without losing the charm that made the first book so beloved. Evie Sage, having survived her unlikely tenure as personal assistant to the realm’s most feared figure, steps further into the Villain’s dangerous world, and the comedy of working in an evil lair gains a layer of genuine emotional weight and real peril. For fans of Assistant to the Villain, it is a satisfying continuation that builds on everything the first book established.

The premise remains irresistible — a workplace comedy set in a villain’s lair — but the sequel proves there is more to mine in it than jokes alone.

The Slow Burn Deepens

The central pleasure of the series is the grumpy-sunshine slow burn between bright, irrepressible Evie and her cold, deeply private employer, and Apprentice advances that relationship meaningfully. The banter-driven tension of the first book matures into something with more vulnerability and higher emotional stakes, as both characters are forced to confront feelings they would rather avoid. Maehrer is careful not to rush — this remains a slow burn — but the connection deepens in ways that reward readers who fell for the dynamic in book one. The longing, the small thawing moments, and the comedy of two guarded people circling each other remain the heart of the story.

Raising the Stakes

Where the first book was content to be cozy and episodic, Apprentice introduces higher emotional stakes and genuine danger. The larger threats that lurked at the edges of book one move closer to the centre, and the plot gains a sharper sense of peril and consequence. This is a careful balancing act — too much darkness would betray the cozy tone, too little would leave the sequel feeling slight — and Maehrer mostly gets the mix right, letting real stakes enter without sacrificing the warmth and humour that define the series. The result is a book with more dramatic weight than its predecessor while remaining recognisably cozy.

Banter and Found Family

The comedy that made the first book a phenomenon is fully present. Maehrer’s gift for deadpan banter, comic timing, and the absurdity of villainous bureaucracy carries through, and the found-family ensemble of lair employees — the misfit community that gives the series its heart — remains a central pleasure. The warmth of that workplace family, now tested by the rising stakes, deepens alongside the romance, and the sense of a cozy community worth returning to is exactly what keeps readers invested in the series.

Charm Over Complexity

As with the first book, Apprentice is not built on intricate plotting or deep worldbuilding. Its strengths are character, humour, and emotional warmth, and readers who want a tightly engineered fantasy plot will find it light. The kingdom, the magic, and the larger conflict remain sketched in service of the comedy and the relationships rather than fully developed, and that is by design. The series knows what it is — a charming, funny, character-driven cozy fantasy — and it stays happily within that lane, delivering exactly the feel-good experience its audience wants.

A Series Built to Continue

Apprentice to the Villain is the second book of an ongoing series, and it advances the larger story while ending on a hook that pulls readers toward the next installment, Accomplice to the Villain. It depends on the first book and rewards readers already invested in Evie and the Villain’s world. As a continuation, it does its job well — deepening what fans loved, raising the stakes enough to keep things fresh, and leaving readers eager for more of the cozy, comedic world Maehrer has built.

The Verdict

Apprentice to the Villain is a warmer, higher-stakes second helping of the cozy-fantasy comedy that made Maehrer’s debut a hit. It deepens the slow-burn romance, raises the emotional stakes and the danger, and keeps the banter and found-family charm that define the series, all while remaining true to its lighthearted register. For readers who loved Assistant to the Villain and want more of its specific feel-good pleasures, it is a satisfying continuation and a reminder of why the series found such a devoted audience.

A Series Built From a Following

The Assistant and the Villain series remains one of the clearest examples of how a social-media following now translates into a publishing career, and Apprentice to the Villain benefits from the close relationship Maehrer maintains with her audience. The series grew from viral TikTok skits into a bestselling franchise, and its instincts — the comic timing, the emotional beats, the found-family warmth — are finely tuned to what that audience loves. Reading the sequel, you sense an author writing in genuine dialogue with her readers, giving them more of the specific pleasures they responded to while carefully deepening the elements that keep a series fresh. That responsiveness is a strength: the book knows exactly what its fans want and delivers it without losing the charm that made the first installment a phenomenon. It is also a reminder that the cozy, comedic corner of romantasy has a large and devoted readership, and that Maehrer is among its most successful and likeable practitioners. For fans who discovered the world through her short-form comedy, the sequel is a natural, welcome continuation of a story they already feel they own.

Our rating: 4.0/5 — A warmer, higher-stakes continuation that deepens the slow-burn romance and raises the danger while keeping the cozy comedy and found-family charm intact.

Explore More

• Browse our full guide to the best romantasy and humor & comedy reads.