Editors Reads Verdict
Madeline Miller's second novel gives voice to one of mythology's most marginalized figures — Circe, the witch-goddess of Aeaea — and in doing so creates the definitive feminist mythological novel of its decade: learned, lyrical, and genuinely moving.
What We Loved
- Miller's prose is among the most beautiful in contemporary fiction
- Circe's development from powerless outcast to confident witch is completely satisfying
- The mythological integration is learned without being academic
- The feminist reading of classical mythology feels earned rather than imposed
- The novel manages genuine complexity in how it treats Circe's famous revenge
Minor Drawbacks
- Readers unfamiliar with Greek mythology may miss some of the resonances
- The pacing in the middle sections slows as Circe's exile becomes genuinely solitary
- Some figures (Odysseus especially) may frustrate readers who love their Homeric versions
Key Takeaways
- → Power developed in isolation has a different quality than power given or inherited
- → The 'monstrous' woman in mythology is often simply the woman who refuses diminishment
- → Immortality without connection is its own form of punishment
- → Magic and craft are the same thing — patience, practice, and willingness to fail
- → The choice to be mortal can be the most courageous choice an immortal makes
| Author | Madeline Miller |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Little, Brown and Company |
| Pages | 393 |
| Published | April 10, 2018 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Mythological Fiction, Fantasy, Literary Fiction |
| Difficulty | Beginner |
| Best For | Readers who love Greek mythology, feminist literary fiction, beautiful prose, and coming-of-power narratives about women who have been historically marginalized. |
Reclaiming the Witch
In Homer’s Odyssey, Circe appears for several chapters as the sorceress who turns Odysseus’s men into pigs and then sleeps with Odysseus for a year before sending him on his way. She is beautiful, dangerous, and entirely defined by her encounters with male heroes. She has no past, no future, no interiority outside her function as obstacle and assistant.
Madeline Miller’s Circe gives her all of these things. The novel is structured as an autobiography that begins before the Trojan War and ends after the Odyssey — spanning millennia of Greek mythological time — and narrates Circe’s development from the voiceless daughter of Helios, mocked by gods and Titans alike for her mortal-seeming quality, to the most powerful witch in the Greek world.
The Development of Power
Miller is interested in how power is actually developed rather than simply discovered. Circe’s witchcraft is not a birthright she suddenly accesses — it is a practice she develops across centuries of solitary experiment, failure, observation, and refinement. The passage that describes her learning to transform creatures through progressive trial and error reads like a description of any genuine craft: iterative, frustrating, requiring the willingness to start over and try differently.
This approach to magic — as patient practice rather than innate gift — is one of the novel’s most interesting formal choices. It also drives the characterization: Circe is not special because she was born special. She is special because she worked at something no one else was willing to work at, in circumstances designed to make success seem impossible.
The Mythological Encounters
Circe’s island becomes a crossroads where figures from across Greek mythology appear: Prometheus, Daedalus, Scylla and Charybdis, Medea, Odysseus and his crew. Miller handles these encounters with impressive integration — each visit is a self-contained story that also advances Circe’s psychological development. The Odysseus section is particularly impressive, capturing a version of the hero that is fully recognizable as Homer’s while being filtered through a perspective Homer never provided.
The Feminist Reading
Circe is explicitly a feminist reclamation project, and Miller is honest about this. But the novel earns its gender politics through character and narrative rather than stating them directly. What becomes clear through Circe’s experience is how completely the mythological world was organized to deny women power and then punish them as monsters when they developed it anyway.
Our rating: 4.5/5 — The definitive feminist mythological novel of its generation: gorgeously written, learned, and built on a protagonist whose voice sounds like something ancient finally speaking in its own tongue.
Ready to Read Circe?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: