Editors Reads Verdict
City of Ashes deepens the Shadowhunter mythology and raises the emotional stakes significantly — a second volume that improves on the debut's formula by embracing the complexity of the revelations from book one.
What We Loved
- The expanded mythology around the Mortal Instruments is handled with genuine skill
- Simon's storyline adds unexpected depth to a character who could have remained comic relief
- The emotional stakes are genuinely higher than in City of Bones
- Clare develops the political dimensions of the Shadowhunter world with more confidence
Minor Drawbacks
- The revelation from book one creates a central tension that some readers find frustrating rather than dramatic
- The pace is slightly uneven in the middle section
- Some plot mechanics require careful attention to the series' internal rules
Key Takeaways
- → Second volumes in fantasy series need to deepen mythology without overwhelming new readers
- → The revelation structure of series fiction requires patience and trust from readers
- → Clare uses the romantic complications to explore identity and belonging rather than just emotion
- → The Downworlder politics become significantly more complex here
- → Simon's transformation subplot is the second book's most interesting contribution
| Author | Cassandra Clare |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Margaret K. McElderry Books |
| Pages | 453 |
| Published | March 25, 2008 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Fantasy, Young Adult |
| Difficulty | Beginner |
| Best For | Readers who have completed City of Bones and are invested in the Shadowhunter world and its characters — not a standalone entry point. |
Raising the Stakes
City of Ashes has a difficult task: it must follow a first novel whose central revelation — the true relationship between Clary and Jace — has permanently altered the reader’s relationship to the series’ central romance. Clare navigates this with reasonable skill, using the complication rather than trying to pretend it away.
Valentine, the novel’s villain and the Shadowhunter world’s most dangerous insurgent, is seeking the remaining Mortal Instruments to summon a demon army that will remake the balance of the Shadow World. Clary, Jace, and their companions must stop him while navigating the political fallout from the Clave’s suspicion of Jace in the wake of his heritage revelation.
Simon’s Transformation
The book’s most genuinely interesting development belongs to Simon, Clary’s mundane best friend. His experience in this volume — and what happens to him as a consequence of it — transforms him from comic relief to one of the series’ most complex figures. Clare is clearly invested in this character in a way that pays off significantly in later volumes.
The Shadowhunter Politics
City of Ashes introduces the Clave — the governing body of the Shadowhunter world — and begins developing the political dimensions of the mythology more fully. The tension between the Downworlders (vampires, werewolves, warlocks, faeries) and the Shadowhunters, and the question of what rights and protections the Accords actually provide, gives the series a more substantial thematic substrate.
Growing Into the Series
Clare’s confidence as a world-builder is visibly growing. The second volume knows what kind of series this is and commits to it without the first novel’s occasional uncertainty.
Our rating: 4.2/5 — A worthy second volume that deepens the mythology and proves the Shadowhunter world has room to grow.
Ready to Read City of Ashes?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: