Layla

Layla Review

Layla is the novel that tests whether readers will follow Colleen Hoover entirely off the map of contemporary romance. Published in 2020, it begins in her established register — Leeds falls fast and genuinely for Layla during a chance encounter, and the early chapters have the warmth of her best work. Then a violent incident at the bed and breakfast where they are staying changes Layla at a neurological level, and the novel becomes something considerably stranger.

Leeds returns to the B&B alone, trying to understand what happened. He meets Willow, a ghost whose situation raises questions he cannot answer honestly without implicating himself. The supernatural machinery is not used for fantasy escapism; Hoover deploys it to ask what it actually means to love a person. Is it the body? The personality? The specific combination of both that existed before trauma rewrote one of them?

The second half tips into thriller territory, and Hoover handles the tonal shift better than expected. The B&B becomes genuinely claustrophobic, the stakes feel real rather than melodramatic, and the final act delivers revelations that reframe earlier scenes in ways that hold up to scrutiny. This is more carefully plotted than most of her work.

The weaknesses are those of ambition. The opening romance is established quickly enough to feel thin, and when the novel needs readers to feel the weight of what Leeds is risking for Layla, the emotional foundation could be deeper. Willow’s backstory also demands a degree of credulity that the atmospheric setup doesn’t fully earn.

But Layla is Hoover working outside her comfort zone with evident intent, and the questions it raises about identity and love are more interesting than the questions posed by most genre fiction.

Our rating: 4.3/5 — Hoover’s most genre-defying novel: a ghost story that uses its supernatural premise to ask serious questions about identity, love, and moral accountability.

Reading Guides

• Colleen Hoover Books in Order: Complete Reading Guide and Where to Start (2026)

Genre Defiance as Deliberate Choice

Hoover has described Layla as the most difficult of her novels to write, which is legible in the finished book. The supernatural premise required her to construct rules — for what Willow is, what she can do, what her history was — that were consistent enough to sustain a thriller structure without becoming so elaborate that they overwhelmed the emotional story. The result is a novel that is lighter on supernatural mechanics than genre readers might prefer while being more emotionally grounded than most paranormal romance.

Published in December 2020 through her own imprint Montlake, Layla arrived during the period when Hoover was building toward the mainstream breakthrough that would come in 2022. It is the most formally experimental novel she published during this period, testing both her own capabilities and her readers’ tolerance for the unexpected. The enthusiastic reception among her existing readership suggested that the audience she had built wanted to follow her into new territory.

What We Love and Who We Love

The novel’s central question — whether Leeds loves Layla the person or Layla as she was before the incident that changed her — is raised obliquely through his developing relationship with Willow, who occupies Layla’s body when Layla is absent. The situation creates a kind of enforced intimacy: Leeds is getting to know Willow as a person while being constantly reminded of Layla by Willow’s physical presence. What he discovers about himself through this situation is more disturbing than he initially allows himself to recognize.

Hoover handles the moral dimension of this with unusual honesty. Leeds is not simply a sympathetic protagonist caught in a strange supernatural situation. He is a person making choices that have ethical implications, and the novel does not entirely let him off the hook for those choices even as it allows the emotional logic to develop naturally. The thriller elements in the second half sharpen this moral accounting considerably.

The B&B as Claustrophobic Space

The bed and breakfast setting — isolated, containing histories that predate the current occupants, and structured around an intimacy enforced by shared domestic space — works because Hoover uses it to generate the kind of tension that requires proximity. Leeds cannot easily leave, and his inability to leave is both practical and emotional: he is here because Layla needs him here, and because something in the situation compels his continued presence in ways he does not fully understand until late in the novel.

The atmosphere Hoover creates is genuinely unsettling in a way her other novels are not. Layla is the book that most clearly demonstrates she could write horror if she chose to — the dread that accumulates across the middle section has a quality distinct from the suspense of Verity or the dark subject matter of It Ends with Us. It is environmental rather than narrative, built from the specific unease of a place where normal rules seem to be in suspension.

Identity After Trauma

The philosophical question at the heart of Layla — whether the person who survives a neurological injury is the same person who sustained it — is one that Hoover approaches through the emotional logic of love rather than through clinical or philosophical frameworks. Leeds does not ask the question in those terms; he asks it in the only terms available to him, which are the terms of his own feelings. Whether he loves the Layla before the incident or the Layla who emerged from it, and whether that distinction is even coherent, is the question he is unable to answer honestly until the novel’s final act forces the issue.

This is also, by extension, a novel about the limits of romantic love as an organizing principle for identity. Leeds defines himself partly through his relationship to Layla; when Layla changes, part of the frame through which he understands himself changes with her. The ghost of Willow complicates this further, offering him a version of intimacy that does not carry the weight of what he and Layla have been through. The novel is interested in which version of connection he chooses, and what that choice reveals about the nature of love itself.