Editors Reads Verdict
Talia Hibbert's second Brown Sisters novel is a masterclass in romantic tension built through character rather than plot, featuring two leads whose refusal to admit their real feelings is entirely specific to who they are rather than generic contrivance.
What We Loved
- Zaf Ansari is one of contemporary romance's most beloved heroes — large, gentle, and emotionally intelligent
- The fake-dating premise is grounded in character rather than pure plot convenience
- Dani's commitment phobia has clear, specific roots that make her behavior understandable
- The portrayal of Zaf's Muslim identity is warm and integrated without being tokenistic
Minor Drawbacks
- Some readers find Dani's internal resistance to commitment frustrating over the book's length
- The social media subplot requires some suspension of disbelief
- A few secondary plot threads are underdeveloped
Key Takeaways
- → Fake relationships create real ones most convincingly when both parties are already halfway there
- → A hero whose emotional intelligence exceeds the heroine's can be romantic rather than emasculating when written with care
- → Commitment phobia in romance is most compelling when it has traceable origins rather than seeming like authorial obstruction
- → Representation of faith in romance can add depth and specificity rather than complicating the romantic arc
- → The friends-to-lovers subtext in fake-dating stories works best when the friendship is genuinely established first
| Author | Talia Hibbert |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Avon |
| Pages | 384 |
| Published | June 23, 2020 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Romance, Contemporary Fiction |
| Difficulty | Beginner |
| Best For | Romance readers who loved Get a Life, Chloe Brown, fans of fake-dating and friends-to-lovers, and anyone drawn to genuinely emotionally intelligent heroes. |
The Second Brown Sister
Danika Brown has a system. She’s a PhD student in Gender Studies, she’s pragmatic about relationships, and she has decided — with some intellectual justification — that romantic love is a social construct she doesn’t need to participate in fully. She’s happy to enjoy the physical benefits of dating while maintaining her independence with meticulous care.
Zafir Ansari has noticed Dani. He’s been noticing her for months, though he’s kept this to himself because Dani has made her position on relationships extremely clear. Then a video of Zaf carrying Dani out of a fire alarm evacuation goes viral, the internet decides they’re a couple, and Zaf proposes they keep up the fiction for the publicity his charity rugby team needs.
Dani, always practical, agrees to a fake relationship with a man she absolutely does not have feelings for.
Zaf Ansari
Hibbert’s second hero is as different from Chloe’s Redford as possible. Where Red was guarded and acerbic, Zaf is openly warm, emotionally fluent, and capable of saying what he means in a way that Dani finds simultaneously disarming and terrifying.
He is a large man who wears his gentleness without apology. He talks about his feelings, he’s thoughtful about his faith, and he is patient with Dani in a way that is clearly not unlimited — the reader sees him absorbing small rejections that have real cost. This makes the eventual resolution feel earned rather than inevitable.
Dani’s Resistance
What distinguishes the book from a standard fake-dating romance is the specificity of Dani’s commitment phobia. It’s not that she hasn’t met the right person — it’s that her family history and her own observations about romantic love have produced a genuinely coherent philosophy about why she shouldn’t want the thing she increasingly wants. Hibbert respects her enough to let this resistance be real rather than dissolving it with a single gesture.
The Hibbert Formula
Hibbert’s second Brown Sisters novel confirms that what makes the series distinctive is not the romantic premises but the character psychology. The plots could belong to dozens of other books. What can’t be replicated is the specific quality of attention she pays to who her characters are and why they’re like that.
Our rating: 4.2/5 — A generous and emotionally intelligent romance featuring one of the genre’s most genuinely appealing heroes.
Ready to Read Take a Hint, Dani Brown?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: