The Ballad of Never After — Once Upon a Broken Heart, Book Two

The Dynamic Deepens

The Ballad of Never After is the second book in Stephanie Garber’s Once Upon a Broken Heart trilogy, and it leans harder into the element that drew readers to the first: the dangerous, swoony dynamic between Evangeline Fox and Jacks, the Prince of Hearts. Picking up after the events of the first book, the sequel binds the two together on a perilous quest, deepening their fraught relationship amid new curses, betrayals, and magic. For fans who fell for the morally complicated chemistry of Once Upon a Broken Heart, The Ballad of Never After delivers more of exactly what they wanted, at higher intensity.

The book raises the stakes and complicates the bargain at the heart of the series, sending Evangeline and Jacks into greater danger and forcing their uneasy bond to bear more weight.

More Romance, More Tension

Where the first book established the Evangeline–Jacks dynamic, the sequel intensifies it. The relationship between the hopeful heroine and the wicked, irresistible Prince of Hearts grows more charged and more central, and Garber leans into the swoony, dangerous chemistry that is the series’ chief pleasure. The push-pull of attraction and mistrust, deepened by the perils they face together, gives The Ballad of Never After a more romance-forward feel than its predecessor, and for readers who came for the morally grey love story, that shift is precisely the appeal.

A Perilous Quest

The plot sends Evangeline and Jacks on a dangerous shared journey, complicated by new curses, magical threats, and the betrayals that are the constant currency of Garber’s world. The quest structure raises the stakes and keeps the two leads in close, fraught proximity, forcing their bond to develop under pressure. The sense of danger and the uncertainty about whom to trust — including, always, Jacks himself — drive the narrative forward and generate the suspense that the series trades in.

Curses, Betrayals, and Magic

Garber continues to build the fairy-tale world of the series, deepening its magic, its curses, and its web of bargains and betrayals. The mythology of the Fates and the rules of the world’s magic grow richer here, giving the romance and the quest a more developed backdrop. The twists come frequently, and the trust-nothing style that defines Garber’s work generates a steady stream of revelations and reversals, keeping readers — like Evangeline — perpetually off-balance.

The Sumptuous Garber Style

The atmosphere that is Garber’s signature carries through fully. The sumptuous, dreamy, slightly sinister enchantment, the lush sensory prose, and the immersive fairy-tale quality all remain, and The Ballad of Never After delivers the beautiful, dangerous dream her readers come for. The visual splendour and magical wonder that defined Caraval and the first Once Upon a Broken Heart book are present in abundance, wrapped around a faster, higher-stakes story.

A Middle Book With a Hook

The Ballad of Never After is the middle volume of the trilogy, and it advances the larger story while ending on a hook designed to make the conclusion, A Curse for True Love, essential. It depends on the first book and deepens rather than resolves the central relationship and conflicts, setting up the finale. For readers invested in Evangeline and Jacks, it is a satisfying escalation that raises both the romantic tension and the stakes heading into the trilogy’s conclusion.

The Verdict

The Ballad of Never After is a deeper, more romance-forward sequel that intensifies the dangerous Evangeline–Jacks dynamic and raises the stakes of Garber’s fairy-tale trilogy. It complicates the bargain, sends its leads on a perilous quest, and leans into the swoony, morally grey chemistry fans crave, all in the sumptuous, dreamy style that defines the series. For readers who loved the first book, it is a thoroughly enchanting continuation that makes the finale impossible to resist.

Feeding the Obsession

Few characters in recent fantasy have inspired the kind of devotion that Jacks, the Prince of Hearts, commands, and The Ballad of Never After understands its assignment perfectly: give the fans more of the dangerous, swoony dynamic they obsess over. By intensifying the Evangeline–Jacks relationship and forcing the two together on a perilous shared quest, Garber leans fully into the morally grey romance that is the series’ beating heart. This is fan service in the best sense — not lazy pandering, but a deliberate deepening of exactly what readers fell in love with. The book’s frequent twists and trust-nothing structure keep the tension high, and the uncertainty about Jacks’s true nature and intentions ensures the romance never settles into comfort. For the enormous, devoted readership of the series, The Ballad of Never After is precisely the escalation they wanted, raising both the romantic stakes and the magical peril and leaving them desperate for the conclusion. It is a middle book that knows exactly what its audience craves and delivers it generously, which is a large part of why the trilogy inspires such passionate engagement. The Prince of Hearts has become one of the genre’s most beloved morally grey love interests, and this middle volume is where his hold on readers’ hearts tightens its grip the most.

Our rating: 4.2/5 — A deeper, more romance-forward sequel that intensifies the dangerous Prince of Hearts dynamic amid new curses and betrayals, in Garber’s sumptuous fairy-tale style.

Explore More

• Browse our full guide to the best romantasy and young adult fantasy.