Editors Reads Verdict
Richard Osman's second Thursday Murder Club novel is larger in scope and sharper in emotional depth than the first, while retaining everything that made the debut so beloved: the four friends, their warmth, their wit, and their unlikely talent for murder investigation.
What We Loved
- Elizabeth's backstory is expanded in ways that add genuine emotional complexity
- The personal stakes make this mystery more emotionally resonant than the first
- Osman's comedy writing is sharper and more confident than in the debut
- The ensemble cast continues to be an extraordinary collective protagonist
Minor Drawbacks
- The plot is more intricate than the first book and occasionally requires careful tracking
- Newcomers to the series will miss the character context from book one
- Some of the thriller plot mechanics feel slightly generic compared to the character work
Key Takeaways
- → The best cozy mysteries are character-driven — the plot is the occasion, not the point
- → Friendship among older people is underrepresented in fiction and immensely valuable when done well
- → Comedy and genuine emotion are not incompatible — the funniest writers often produce the most moving scenes
- → Investigative competence in amateur detectives requires some plausible source of skill
- → Series mysteries succeed when the recurring characters develop across books rather than resetting
| Author | Richard Osman |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Pamela Dorman Books |
| Pages | 352 |
| Published | September 16, 2021 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Cozy Mystery, Crime Fiction, Comedy |
| Difficulty | Beginner |
| Best For | Readers who loved The Thursday Murder Club and anyone who enjoys cozy British mysteries with warmth, wit, and genuinely clever plotting. |
The Club Investigates Again
The Thursday Murder Club was officially formed to review cold cases from the retirement community Coopers Chase. In practice, as the first novel established, they investigate rather more active murders with rather more personal investment. The four members — Elizabeth, Joyce, Ibrahim, and Ron — are back in their second case, and this time the personal stakes are higher than before.
When Elizabeth’s ex-husband Douglas turns up at Coopers Chase with stolen diamonds and an assassin apparently on his trail, the case becomes less an intellectual exercise and more an existential one. Someone Elizabeth loved and lost has reappeared with danger attached, and the mystery of who he is now — and what he got into — requires the Club’s full attention.
Elizabeth
One of the pleasures of the series is that Osman gradually reveals the depths of his characters across books. The Man Who Died Twice is Elizabeth’s book in ways the first wasn’t. Her past — professionally distinguished, personally complicated — is given more room to expand, and the result is a character who is funnier and more affecting than the first book entirely promised.
Her relationship with Douglas, whatever it was and whatever it cost her, gives the investigation an emotional undertow that elevates it above standard cozy mystery conventions.
The Ensemble
Joyce, Ibrahim, and Ron continue to be individually wonderful and collectively extraordinary. Osman writes group scenes with a social intelligence that captures the particular pleasures of old friendships — the shorthand, the teasing, the love that is expressed through competition rather than sentiment.
The running joke that the Club is consistently more effective than the police is handled with more awareness here: Donna and Bogdan are given enough development to feel like characters rather than foils.
The Comedy
The Thursday Murder Club series may be the funniest ongoing British mystery since Alexander McCall Smith, and this book is sharper than the debut. Osman’s comic instinct is for the small, specific, true observation — the kind of joke that makes you recognize something you’ve seen but never articulated.
Our rating: 4.3/5 — A warmer, more emotionally complex second novel that confirms the Thursday Murder Club as one of contemporary crime fiction’s best ensembles.
Ready to Read The Man Who Died Twice?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: