Editors Reads Verdict
Eclipse is often considered the saga's best-paced installment — the love triangle reaches its peak intensity while an external threat provides genuine action stakes and the backstory chapters for Jasper and Rosalie add unexpected depth.
What We Loved
- The love triangle reaches its most emotionally intense and honestly complicated point
- The vampire and werewolf alliance provides genuinely exciting action sequences
- Jasper and Rosalie backstory chapters are the saga's finest character writing
- The choice Bella faces is rendered with more moral complexity than the first two books
Minor Drawbacks
- At 629 pages, the book is longer than the story requires
- Some readers find the love triangle dynamic repetitive across installments
- The resolution of Bella's choice raises questions about what she's sacrificing
Key Takeaways
- → Real choices involve genuine loss — selecting one option means foreclosing another
- → External threats can clarify internal priorities
- → Characters' backstories explain current behavior in ways that create empathy
- → Alliance between natural enemies requires shared stakes that override instinct
- → The best love triangles make both options genuinely appealing
| Author | Stephenie Meyer |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Little, Brown Books for Young Readers |
| Pages | 629 |
| Published | August 7, 2007 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Young Adult, Fantasy, Romance |
| Difficulty | Beginner |
| Best For | Readers progressing through the Twilight saga who want the love triangle at its most dramatic and the action elements at their most developed. |
The Best of the Middle Books
Eclipse is generally regarded as the strongest of the Twilight saga’s middle volumes, and the assessment is fair. Meyer finds the balance here that the series had been working toward: the romantic triangle is at maximum intensity (Jacob’s feelings for Bella are explicit; her feelings for him are genuinely complicated), the external threat (a newborn vampire army raised by Riley at Victoria’s direction) provides stakes that extend beyond Bella’s romantic predicament, and the backstory chapters — particularly those for Jasper and Rosalie — are the finest character writing in the entire saga.
Rosalie’s chapter is especially striking. Her account of her own death and transformation is genuinely dark in ways that the series doesn’t typically allow, and her perspective on Bella’s desire to become a vampire — written from the experience of someone who cannot undo the transformation she underwent involuntarily — is the series’ most morally complex material.
The Choice
The emotional center of Eclipse is Bella’s genuine conflict between Edward and Jacob — and Meyer is more honest here than in New Moon about the fact that both options represent real losses. Choosing Edward means losing Jacob; choosing Jacob means losing Edward. The love triangle works because both relationships are shown to be real, both to Bella and to the reader.
The tent scene — in which Jacob and Edward coexist in close quarters out of necessity, with Bella literally between them — is the saga’s most effectively staged comic-dramatic set-piece.
The Alliance
The vampire-werewolf alliance against the newborn army requires both factions to overcome instinctive hostility for a shared goal. Meyer handles this with more sophistication than might be expected, using the alliance to develop Seth Clearwater as a character and to give Edward and Jacob their most productive interaction of the series.
The battle sequences are also the most action-focused material the saga had produced to this point.
Our rating: 3.8/5 — The Twilight saga’s most balanced installment, with the love triangle at its most honest, genuine action stakes, and the series’ richest character backstory work.
Ready to Read Eclipse?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: