Editors Reads Verdict
New Moon is the Twilight saga's most emotionally honest entry — its extended depiction of post-breakup depression is surprisingly raw, and Jacob Black's introduction creates the love triangle that would define the remainder of the series.
What We Loved
- The extended depression sequence is unusually honest about how abandonment feels
- Jacob Black is a more fully realized character than Edward in many respects
- The Volturi world-building expands the mythology meaningfully
- The cliff-jumping scene as depression-as-adrenaline-seeking is psychologically accurate
Minor Drawbacks
- The middle section is deliberately slow in ways that test readers' patience
- Bella's dependence on external figures for her sense of self becomes more pronounced
- The resolution requires accepting some significant plot conveniences
Key Takeaways
- → Grief after loss of relationship can be as acute as grief after death
- → Rebound relationships often provide genuine support rather than mere distraction
- → Adrenaline-seeking as a method of feeling present is a real psychological phenomenon
- → Chosen family (the wolf pack) can provide what biological family cannot
- → The Volturi sequence demonstrates that stakes in vampire fiction can be genuinely global
| Author | Stephenie Meyer |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Little, Brown Books for Young Readers |
| Pages | 563 |
| Published | September 6, 2006 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Young Adult, Fantasy, Romance |
| Difficulty | Beginner |
| Best For | Readers who completed Twilight and want to continue the saga — particularly those interested in the Jacob arc and the expansion of the vampire world. |
The Darkest Installment
Meyer made a difficult creative choice with New Moon: she removed the element — Edward — that had driven the first book’s momentum and replaced him with months of depicted depression. The famous blank pages marking months of Bella’s paralysis are either a bold formal experiment or an irritant, depending on what you want from the series.
What New Moon offers in place of Edward is Jacob Black — warmer, more present, more emotionally legible, and (it eventually becomes clear) a werewolf who imprints on members of his pack’s ancestral community. Jacob’s competition with Edward for Bella’s affection created the Team Edward/Team Jacob dynamic that drove the cultural conversation around the series for years.
Depression as Subject
The book’s most surprising element is its sustained engagement with depression. Bella’s months of paralysis after Edward’s departure — the blank chapter headings marking time she can’t experience — capture something real about major depressive episodes: the way time empties of content, the way the person who was there becomes the organizing absence around which everything else arranges itself.
This is not sophisticated literary treatment of depression. But it’s more honest than most YA fiction of the era was willing to be about what abandonment by a central relationship can do to an adolescent’s sense of self.
Jacob’s Counterpoint
What Jacob offers Bella is warmth, presence, and the specific healing that comes from someone who wants to be with you rather than someone whose staying required supernatural effort. The Jacob chapters are New Moon’s best — Meyer writes their friendship with more relaxed affection than she brings to the Edward sequences, and Jacob’s eventual revelation doesn’t diminish the friendship that preceded it.
The Volturi sequence in the final third introduces the saga’s larger supernatural power structure and sets up the stakes that will drive the remaining two books.
Our rating: 3.7/5 — The saga’s most emotionally serious installment, with a raw depiction of post-relationship depression and Jacob Black’s compelling introduction partially offsetting the deliberate pacing challenges of its middle section.
Ready to Read New Moon?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: