Editors Reads Verdict
Rowell's most personally resonant novel is a love letter to fan fiction as a form and to introversion as a valid way of being, wrapped in a college romance that is warm without being saccharine. It captures the anxiety of transition with rare accuracy.
What We Loved
- The most accurate portrayal of fan fiction culture and community in mainstream fiction
- Cath's social anxiety is rendered with specificity and compassion
- The Simon Snow meta-text woven throughout is clever and emotionally resonant
- The romance is slow, sweet, and entirely believable
Minor Drawbacks
- The pacing in the middle third is leisurely
- Wren's storyline is less developed than Cath's
- Some readers find the college setting too insular
Key Takeaways
- → Fan fiction is a legitimate creative form and community, not a lesser practice
- → The transition to college isolates introverts in ways that are rarely acknowledged
- → Letting someone into your private world is itself an act of intimacy
- → Identity is more entangled with our creative loves than we generally admit
- → Siblings can be so close that separation feels like a kind of loss
| Author | Rainbow Rowell |
|---|---|
| Publisher | St. Martin's Griffin |
| Pages | 459 |
| Published | September 10, 2013 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Young Adult, Contemporary Fiction |
| Difficulty | Beginner |
| Best For | YA readers; fans of fan fiction; introverts navigating new social environments. |
The Girl Who Writes
Cath Avery has spent four years writing fan fiction about Simon Snow — a Harry Potter-esque fantasy series — and her stories have accumulated hundreds of thousands of readers. She arrives at the University of Nebraska with a folder of notes for her magnum opus: the novel-length fan fiction that will complete Simon’s story before the official final volume does. Her twin sister Wren is done with Simon Snow and wants to reinvent herself at college. Cath does not know how to be herself without Wren, and without Simon Snow.
Fan Fiction as Literature
Rowell’s treatment of fan fiction is the novel’s most unusual and valuable contribution to YA literature. Most mainstream fiction treats fan fiction as embarrassing or juvenile; Rowell treats it as what it actually is — a creative community with its own traditions, its own craft standards, and its own forms of mentorship and feedback. Cath is a gifted writer, and her fan fiction is shown as genuinely accomplished. Her struggle to transition to writing original fiction is the struggle of any writer learning that the training wheels they’ve outgrown were still training wheels.
Anxiety and College
Cath’s social anxiety is rendered without either minimizing it or making it a source of drama. She orders energy bars online rather than navigate the dining hall. She finds the noise and enforced sociability of dormitory life genuinely overwhelming. She retreats to her room and her laptop and Simon Snow. Rowell treats these responses as comprehensible and adaptive rather than pathological — Cath has found a way to survive, and the novel is the story of her slowly building enough trust to live differently.
Reagan and Levi
The supporting characters are among Rowell’s warmest. Reagan, Cath’s roommate, is the kind of person who seems designed to make introverts miserable and ends up being essential. Levi, the farm-boy who always seems to be in their room, is one of YA romance’s most uncomplicated delights — straightforward, kind, genuinely interested in Cath’s work. Their romance develops at the pace of real friendship.
Our rating: 4.2/5 — A warm, funny, and unexpectedly profound novel about creativity, transition, and the courage it takes to let people into your inner world.
Ready to Read Fangirl?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: