Editors Reads Verdict
Austen's first published novel is less perfect than her later work but no less intelligent — and the character who seems to represent unchecked sensibility (Marianne) and the one who represents cool sense (Elinor) both turn out to be more complicated than the novel's allegorical title promises.
What We Loved
- Elinor is one of Austen's most admirable heroines — her self-control is depicted as heroism, not coldness
- Willoughby's belated explanation of his behaviour is unusually sympathetic for a villain
- The economic constraints on the Dashwood women are drawn with characteristic precision
- The novel complicates its own title — neither 'sense' nor 'sensibility' is presented as simply superior
Minor Drawbacks
- Colonel Brandon suffers from being a character assembled to specifications rather than observed from life
- Edward Ferrars is the least vivid of Austen's romantic heroes
- The plotting in the final third is less elegant than Austen's later work
Key Takeaways
- → Emotional expressiveness is not the same as emotional depth — Marianne feels deeply but communicates shallowly
- → Social convention, however constraining, exists partly to protect the vulnerable — Elinor's sense is not mere conformity
- → The capacity to feel and the capacity to endure feeling are different qualities, each of which the sisters must learn
- → Economic dependence shapes every emotional possibility — the Dashwoods' lack of money is not background but foreground
- → Willoughby's choice of money over Marianne is presented as comprehensible rather than simply villainous
| Author | Jane Austen |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Penguin Classics |
| Pages | 384 |
| Published | October 30, 1811 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Fiction, Classic Literature, Romance |
| Difficulty | Beginner |
| Best For | Readers who want to understand Austen's development as a novelist — and those who appreciate how a literary opposition (sense vs. sensibility) can be systematically and sympathetically complicated. |
Austen’s First and Most Personal Novel
Begun in 1795, when Austen was around nineteen, and published in 1811 as her debut novel, Sense and Sensibility carries the marks of its origins: it is the roughest and most schematic of her mature work, but it also contains some of her most emotionally direct writing, and the Elinor-Marianne opposition is more nuanced than the allegorical title suggests.
The Dashwood sisters have been made dependent by their father’s death: the Dashwood estate passes to their half-brother, and their mother and three daughters are left with a small income and Barton Cottage in Devonshire. Into this genteel poverty come two men: Edward Ferrars, gentle and honest but encumbered by a secret prior engagement; and John Willoughby, dashing, literary, and attentive to Marianne — and concealing motivations that will prove destructive.
The Opposition and Its Complications
The novel’s allegorical structure — Elinor as sense, Marianne as sensibility — is both the work’s dominant organising principle and its most interesting problem. Elinor, twenty years old, is one of Austen’s most admirable creations: she maintains composure while suffering privately (her feelings for Edward are genuine and deeply felt, just rigorously controlled), and her self-control is explicitly presented as a form of heroism rather than emotional poverty.
Marianne, seventeen, loves Willoughby extravagantly and publicly, and is correspondingly devastated by his abandonment. Her sensibility — her openness to feeling, her contempt for social constraint — is depicted sympathetically but also critically: it is partly self-indulgence, a preference for the performance of emotion over the management of it.
Austen’s complication is that Elinor must learn to express herself and Marianne must learn to endure — neither sister’s mode is sufficient, and the marriages at the end represent not the triumph of sense over sensibility but a synthesis of both.
Willoughby: The Villain Explained
Willoughby’s late scene — in which he visits Elinor and explains his conduct with a candour and partial self-knowledge unusual in Austen’s villains — is one of the novel’s most interesting moments. He did genuinely love Marianne. He chose money over her with full awareness of what he was doing. His marriage to Miss Grey is not evil but mercenary, motivated by the same economic pressures that shape everyone else’s choices in the novel. Austen does not exonerate him but she refuses to make him simply monstrous.
Colonel Brandon
Colonel Brandon, Marianne’s eventual husband, has been unkindly described by critics as a wish-fulfilment figure assembled by Austen to provide a decent outcome for a heroine who can’t have Willoughby. He is flannel waistcoats and steady affection. He is not wrong as a choice. But he is the least vivid of Austen’s romantic heroes, and the novel knows it.
Our rating: 4.4/5 — Less perfectly achieved than Austen’s later novels but more personally felt — essential for understanding how she developed her craft.
Ready to Read Sense and Sensibility?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: