Editors Reads Verdict
Starsight is a bold expansion of the Skyward universe that sends Spensa into enemy territory and forces both protagonist and reader to question every assumption established in book one. The undercover structure is handled with real skill, the alien ensemble is diverse and genuinely alien, and the revelation about cytonic abilities fundamentally reframes the series.
What We Loved
- The undercover structure forces Spensa to genuinely understand the enemy's perspective
- The alien characters are diverse and conceived with real imagination rather than human-with-forehead-ridges design
- The revelation about what the Krell actually are is a genuine surprise with retroactive power
- Kimmalyn and the supporting cast back on Detritus have meaningful storylines
Minor Drawbacks
- Spensa's voice changes significantly when she's undercover, which readers who loved book one may miss
- The pacing in the middle section among the Superiority is slower than Skyward's breakneck pace
- Some alien cultures are more developed than others
Key Takeaways
- → Understanding the enemy does not mean agreeing with them — but it does change the moral landscape of the conflict
- → Systems of oppression rarely present themselves as such to those who benefit from them
- → The most effective undercover stories require the protagonist to find genuine sympathy for those they're investigating
- → Self-discovery is more frightening when it reveals that you are more like the enemy than you assumed
- → Propaganda works on both sides — questioning your own society's narrative is an act of courage
| Author | Brandon Sanderson |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Delacorte Press |
| Pages | 461 |
| Published | November 26, 2019 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Science Fiction, Fantasy, Young Adult |
| Difficulty | Beginner |
| Best For | Readers of Skyward continuing the series; YA SF fans interested in first contact and alien culture dynamics; readers who want their military SF to have moral complexity. |
Behind Enemy Lines
Skyward spent its entire length establishing the Krell as an existential threat — a faceless alien force that destroys any human pilot who attempts to flee the battlefield. Starsight immediately complicates this picture. Spensa’s cytonic abilities allow her to communicate across space, and when she receives an alien transmission, she uses it to infiltrate the Superiority — the interstellar polity that controls the Krell — as a pilot trainee from a subject species.
The undercover structure is the right choice for a series that has been building toward the question “what do the Krell actually want?” It forces Spensa to engage with the answer personally rather than discovering it as external information, which is a better narrative solution and a more uncomfortable one.
The Superiority
The alien cultures of the Superiority are Starsight’s greatest achievement. Rather than building a monolithic enemy species, Sanderson creates a coalition of multiple alien peoples, each with distinct physiologies and cultures, united by a shared political philosophy — that “aggressor species” (including humans) are too dangerous to be allowed interstellar travel. The irony that the Superiority considers humanity irredeemably aggressive while conducting a multi-generation war of suppression against them is not lost on Spensa, and her attempts to articulate this to herself while maintaining her cover is where the book does its best character work.
Brade — the other human-seeming pilot in Spensa’s flight group — is the series’ most morally complex character, someone who has genuinely internalized the Superiority’s values and uses them as a weapon against her own species.
What the Krell Are
The revelation of the Krell’s actual nature — remote-piloted drones, not independent beings — fundamentally changes the moral calculus of every battle in Skyward. Spensa has been celebrating her kills; now she understands what she has actually been killing, and what the humans who fight alongside her have been doing. This is a more sophisticated ethical complication than most YA military fiction attempts, and Sanderson gives it the weight it deserves.
Our rating: 4.3/5 — A confident expansion that rewards series investment with moral complexity, alien world-building, and a protagonist forced to genuinely understand her enemies.
Ready to Read Starsight?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: