The Republic of Thieves

The Return After Six Years

Fans of the Gentlemen Bastards series waited six years between Red Seas Under Red Skies and The Republic of Thieves — years during which Lynch dealt with severe depression and creative difficulties that he has discussed publicly. The wait, and its reasons, are worth acknowledging because the novel that finally arrived was clearly written under strain and represents both the series at its most emotionally ambitious and at its most structurally complicated.

Locke Lamora is dying. The poison that has been working through him since the end of the second book has reached a stage that Jean’s nursing and available medicine cannot address. Then the Bondsmagi — the powerful fraternity of magic users who have been the series’ shadowy antagonists — offer a cure in exchange for a job: travel to the city of Karthain and run the electoral campaign for one of the two factions competing for control of the city’s government. The catch is that the opposing campaign will be managed by Sabetha.

Sabetha

From the first novel’s early scenes, Sabetha Belacoros has been the character the reader most wanted to meet — Locke’s equal, his obsession, the one person whose opinion of him he cannot manage. Lynch had been building toward her for two novels, which is a lot of anticipation to satisfy. He largely succeeds. Sabetha is formidably intelligent, aware of exactly how Locke sees her and exactly how to use that, and carrying her own history of damage that is not about Locke at all. She is the most complete character in the series.

Theatre and Politics

The alternating flashback sequences — set during the young Gentlemen Bastards’ participation in a theatrical production, under the direction of their mentor Chains — are among Lynch’s most purely enjoyable writing. The comedy of young criminals learning to perform, of Locke’s early romantic disasters with Sabetha, and of Chains’s idiosyncratic pedagogy gives the novel a warmth and lightness that the present-timeline political machinations can occasionally lack.

The election-rigging plot, with Locke and Sabetha competing to out-manoeuvre each other while also being covertly attracted to each other, is satisfying in its mechanics and emotionally complex in its implications.

A Romance Built on Rivalry

The genius of the central setup is that it forces the long-awaited romance and a high-stakes contest into the same space. Locke and Sabetha are not only former lovers reunited after years apart; they are opposing generals in a rigged election, each commanding a faction, each trying to outwit the other while neither can quite suppress the old attraction. This collision of professional rivalry and personal longing gives the novel its distinctive charge. Lynch resists the easy version in which love conquers all; instead, Sabetha consistently sees through Locke’s charm, refuses to be managed, and challenges him on the very self-deceptions that the reader has come to find endearing. Their relationship is prickly, intelligent, and frequently frustrating in exactly the ways real entanglements between two strong-willed people are — which is far more interesting than a tidy fairy tale would have been.

The Heart of the Gentlemen Bastards

For all its plot machinery, the book’s deepest pleasure remains the friendship between Locke and Jean Tannen, the surviving heart of the once-larger Gentlemen Bastards. After two books of loss — the crew that began the series has been steadily, brutally thinned — the bond between these two con men, equal parts banter and unspoken devotion, is the emotional anchor that keeps the increasingly elaborate plotting grounded. The flashbacks to their youth under the tutelage of their mentor Father Chains restore the full ensemble to the page and remind us what the present timeline has cost them. Lynch’s gift for found family, for the loyalty among thieves who have nothing in the world but each other, is what has always elevated the series above clever heist mechanics, and it is on full display here.

A Series at a Crossroads

The Republic of Thieves also pushes the series’ larger mythology forward in ways that reshape everything. The Bondsmagi, previously shadowy antagonists, move to center stage, and the novel ends with revelations about Locke’s true origins and the magi’s interest in him that crack open the saga’s overarching mystery — while pointedly leaving much unresolved. This is both thrilling and frustrating: it signals genuine ambition for where the series is heading, but it also raises questions the book cannot answer on its own, leaving readers dependent on sequels that have been slow to arrive. As the third of a projected seven-book series, it carries the structural burden of a middle volume, advancing the long game more than it concludes anything.

Strengths and Weaknesses

The novel’s strengths are considerable: a triumphant introduction of Sabetha, some of Lynch’s funniest and warmest writing in the theatrical flashbacks, and a clever, emotionally layered central plot. Its weaknesses are largely a matter of expectation and structure. Six years of anticipation is an impossible weight for any book to bear, and the novel — clearly written through real personal difficulty — is more setup-heavy and less self-contained than the propulsive Lies of Locke Lamora. The election plot, while inventive, lacks the desperate stakes of the first book’s con, and the dangling mysteries test the patience of readers awaiting the series’ continuation. It is a strong, transitional entry rather than a standalone triumph.

Our rating: 4.1/5 — A warm, witty, emotionally ambitious third Gentlemen Bastards novel that finally delivers Sabetha and deepens the saga’s mythology — more transitional setup than self-contained triumph, but essential for fans of Locke and Jean.

Reading Guides

• Best Fantasy Books of All Time: 25 Essential Epics (2026)