The Silmarillion

A Mythology, Not a Novel

The most important thing to understand about The Silmarillion is what it is not. It is not a sequel to The Lord of the Rings. It is not a novel with a protagonist and a narrative arc. It is the foundational mythology of Middle-earth — the Iliad and Genesis and Prose Edda of Tolkien’s invented world, assembled after his death by his son Christopher from decades of manuscripts, notes, and revisions.

Tolkien spent most of his adult life writing and rewriting these legends. He never finished them to his satisfaction, and he never published them in his lifetime. What Christopher Tolkien assembled and published in 1977, four years after his father’s death, is not a finished work in the conventional sense. It is a compilation — edited, shaped, and connected — from a vast archive of material. Some sections are polished and luminous. Others feel like genealogical inventory. Both qualities are intrinsic to the project, and readers who arrive expecting the paced narrative pleasure of The Hobbit or The Fellowship will be disoriented.

The Creation and the First Age

The book opens with the Ainulindalë, Tolkien’s creation myth: Ilúvatar the god-figure invites the divine Ainur to make music together, and from that music the world is created. When the most powerful Ainur, Melkor, introduces discordant themes out of pride, Ilúvatar absorbs even the discord into a greater design. It is a stunningly beautiful piece of theological imagination — one of the finest things Tolkien ever wrote — and it establishes the metaphysical stakes for everything that follows.

What follows is the chronicle of the First Age: the making of the Two Trees that light the world before the Sun and Moon, the creation of the Silmarils by the greatest of the Elven craftsmen, the theft of those jewels by Melkor (here called Morgoth), and the millennia-long war by the Elves to recover them. The tales of Beren and Lúthien, of Túrin Turambar, of the hidden city of Gondolin and its fall — these are the stories that give The Lord of the Rings its backstory, the ancient tragedies that Tolkien’s characters in the Third Age are dimly remembering when they speak of the Elder Days.

The Reward for Patient Readers

The density is real and the prose is demanding. Characters arrive with multiple names in different languages. Events are summarised across centuries in a single paragraph; other events receive pages of attention. The register is consistently high and mythological, and readers who need character interiority or novelistic pacing will find long stretches of the Quenta Silmarillion hard going.

But the rewards for persistence are extraordinary. The story of Beren — mortal, wounded, apparently doomed — who wins the hand of the immortal Lúthien Tinúviel in exchange for retrieving a Silmaril from the crown of a Dark Lord is the emotional core of the book and one of the great love stories in English literature. Tolkien wrote it first as a poem and returned to it throughout his life; he had “Lúthien” inscribed on his wife Edith’s grave, and “Beren” on his own.

Reading The Silmarillion after The Lord of the Rings is transformative. The allusions that felt ornamental in Tolkien’s novel — to Gil-galad, to Eärendil, to the Silmarils, to the dark lord before Sauron — suddenly acquire full weight. Middle-earth stops being a stage set and becomes a world with a real past, shaped by real losses. For the right reader, there is nothing quite like it.

Our rating: 4.2/5 — Essential for serious Tolkien readers; impenetrable for anyone else. Read The Lord of the Rings first, and treat this as the mythology behind the mythology.