Editors Reads Verdict
Gregory Maguire's revisionist fantasy is a politically sophisticated novel that uses the familiar world of Oz to explore questions of evil, identity, and how history is written by those who win — demanding and ambitious, if uneven in its latter sections.
What We Loved
- The political allegory operates with genuine sophistication — Oz as a totalitarian state is fully developed
- Elphaba is one of fantasy's most psychologically complex protagonists
- The revisionist framework raises real questions about the nature of evil and moral judgment
- The first half is among the most inventive fantasy fiction of its era
- Provides entirely new ways of reading the original Baum books and the 1939 film
Minor Drawbacks
- The pacing becomes uneven after the Shiz sections — the middle third loses momentum
- Some readers find the ending abrupt after such lengthy buildup
- The political allegory occasionally overwhelms the character development
Key Takeaways
- → History is always written by the victors — the Wicked Witch's story is never that simple
- → Evil is rarely born; it is made by circumstance, prejudice, and the cruelty of others
- → Political systems that fear difference will always manufacture enemies to justify themselves
- → Identity imposed from outside can become a prison even when resisted from within
| Author | Gregory Maguire |
|---|---|
| Publisher | HarperCollins |
| Pages | 406 |
| Published | October 1, 1995 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Fantasy, Literary Fiction, Revisionist Fiction |
| Difficulty | Intermediate |
| Best For | Readers who want literary depth in their fantasy, fans of the original Oz, and anyone intrigued by revisionist retellings of familiar stories. |
Before Dorothy Dropped In
Gregory Maguire’s 1995 novel arrives with a premise so elegant it seems obvious in retrospect: what if the Wicked Witch of the West had a story? What if she wasn’t wicked at all — or rather, what if wickedness was something that happened to her rather than something she was born with?
The novel follows Elphaba from birth (her emerald skin immediately marking her as Other) through her years at Shiz University, where she meets the blonde, popular Galinda who will become Glinda the Good, and into her eventual role as political dissident and revolutionary in a country ruled by a Wizard whose benevolent reputation conceals something considerably darker.
Oz as Totalitarian State
Maguire’s most sustained achievement is the reimagining of Oz as a functioning political system rather than a dream landscape. The Emerald City is a capital city that enforces conformity; the Wizard’s regime suppresses the rights of Animals (sentient creatures who are losing the ability to speak under mysterious circumstances that suspiciously correlate with official policy); the Gale Force police enforce order with methods that don’t bear examination. Elphaba becomes a revolutionary not out of wickedness but out of conscience.
The Making of a Villain
The novel asks its central question directly: what does it take to make someone a villain? Maguire’s answer is detailed and uncomfortable. It involves prejudice encountered from birth, love lost, causes failed, and finally the realization that history will record you however it finds useful regardless of what you actually did. Elphaba’s famous greenness is a metaphor for any difference that makes you target — she never chose it, never accepted it, but can never escape it.
The Shiz Years
The strongest sections of the novel follow Elphaba and Galinda through their university years — an odd-couple friendship that develops with real psychological texture. Galinda’s journey from shallow self-interest toward something approaching genuine goodness is as interesting as Elphaba’s, and their antagonism-become-friendship provides the novel’s warmest and most human material.
Our rating: 4.1/5 — An ambitious, politically sophisticated fantasy that retells a beloved story and asks uncomfortable questions about evil, identity, and who gets to write history.
Ready to Read Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: