Editors Reads Verdict
Widely considered the high point of the entire series, the third Westeros novel contains more plot-defining events per page than almost any fantasy novel ever written, including the Red Wedding — perhaps the most shocking sequence in modern genre fiction.
What We Loved
- The Red Wedding is one of fiction's most devastating and technically brilliant sequences
- Multiple character arcs reach satisfying and shattering conclusions
- Jaime Lannister's transformation is one of the series' finest character achievements
- The sheer density of plot events is staggering and yet controlled
Minor Drawbacks
- At 1128 pages, the commitment is considerable
- The Daenerys chapters in the east feel slightly disconnected from the main action
- Some resolutions arrive so quickly that the reader barely has time to process them
Key Takeaways
- → Genre conventions can be violated to devastating effect when the violation is principled
- → Character development across hundreds of pages earns emotional payoffs unavailable in shorter forms
- → Honor and survival are frequently incompatible
- → The reader's attachment to characters is a tool the author can use against them
- → Even in fantasy, there are no plot armors if the author is honest
| Author | George R.R. Martin |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Bantam Books |
| Pages | 1128 |
| Published | August 8, 2000 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Fantasy, Epic Fantasy |
| Difficulty | Intermediate |
| Best For | Fans of the series; epic fantasy readers willing to commit to the scale. |
The Peak of the Mountain
Every long series has a book where it either justifies its length or reveals itself as self-indulgent. “A Storm of Swords” is the rare volume that does more than justify its series — it transcends it, producing a novel that stands as one of the finest achievements in fantasy fiction by any measure. The War of the Five Kings ends here, in ways that few readers predicted and none who experienced it have forgotten.
The Red Wedding
It is difficult to discuss “A Storm of Swords” without discussing the Red Wedding, though to reveal its specifics is a crime against future readers. What can be said: Martin takes the fantasy genre’s deepest convention — that protagonists survive because they are protagonists — and violates it so completely and with such calculated precision that readers have literally reported physical symptoms of shock. The sequence is preceded by chapters of careful narrative misdirection that make the event both more shocking and, on re-reading, entirely inevitable. It is a masterpiece of literary timing.
Jaime Lannister, Remade
In the first two novels, Jaime Lannister functions largely as villain — the Kingslayer, the man who murdered the king he swore to protect. “A Storm of Swords” is the novel in which Martin reveals the complexity beneath that villainy. Travelling with Brienne of Tarth, losing his sword hand, telling his story for the first time, Jaime becomes one of the most fully realized characters in the series. The Kingslayer’s explanation of what actually happened in the throne room is one of Martin’s finest passages.
Multiple Endings
Other fantasy series of this scale reserve their major events for the final volume. Martin detonates major events throughout, so that by the time the novel’s actual ending arrives, the reader has already been shocked multiple times and is no longer confident about what is possible. This is the great technical achievement of “A Storm of Swords”: it teaches readers that anything can happen, and then delivers on that lesson repeatedly.
Our rating: 4.7/5 — The finest volume in the series and one of the great achievements in fantasy fiction, containing the Red Wedding and a dozen other moments of shattering narrative precision.
Ready to Read A Storm of Swords?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: