Editors Reads Verdict
Firefight improves on Steelheart's formula by deepening the philosophical question at the series' core: if power corrupts every Epic, why? The flooded Manhattan setting is more atmospherically interesting than Newcago, and the introduction of Megan's storyline adds genuine emotional complexity to what could have been a straightforward sequel.
What We Loved
- Babylon Restored is a richer, more visually distinctive setting than Newcago
- The question of Epic psychology — why corruption is universal — is developed with real depth
- Megan's storyline adds emotional stakes that the series needed
- The action sequences in a flooded city are some of Sanderson's most inventive choreography
Minor Drawbacks
- Some middle-book pacing issues slow the momentum established in Steelheart
- Secondary Reckoners remain underdeveloped relative to the main cast
- The villain's master plan becomes clear too early
Key Takeaways
- → The most interesting questions in a series are introduced when the central premise is challenged rather than confirmed
- → Settings that reflect thematic content — flooding as loss of control — do narrative work without being heavy-handed
- → Romantic relationships in YA work best when the love interest challenges the protagonist's core assumptions
- → Why corruption happens matters as much as the fact that it happens
- → Hope for individual exceptions doesn't require abandoning the systemic analysis
| Author | Brandon Sanderson |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Delacorte Press |
| Pages | 416 |
| Published | January 6, 2015 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Science Fiction, Fantasy, Young Adult |
| Difficulty | Beginner |
| Best For | Readers of Steelheart continuing the series; YA readers who want action with genuine philosophical content; fans of the superhero genre interested in its darker possibilities. |
Babylon Restored
The city-as-character principle that made Newcago work in Steelheart is applied to a new setting in Firefight, and the result is arguably more interesting. Babylon Restored is the flooded remains of Manhattan, its skyscrapers rising from artificial seas created by an Epic’s power, its population living on upper floors and bridges and the rooftops of submerged buildings. The verticality of the original city is preserved while being completely transformed — and in a story about power that distorts everything it touches, this is a setting that does genuine thematic work.
Regalia, the Epic who controls Babylon Restored, is a more sophisticated antagonist than Steelheart. Where Steelheart was power in its most naked form — domination, fear, control — Regalia has a plan that involves the Reckoners specifically and David in particular, which makes her more interesting as a villain and raises the stakes of the eventual confrontation.
The Question the Series Needed
Steelheart proposed that all Epics are corrupt because of their power. Firefight asks: why? If the corruption is universal, it must have a cause, and understanding the cause might suggest something about whether the corruption is truly inevitable. David’s growing attachment to Megan — an Epic who seems to be fighting the corruption with partial success — is not just a romantic subplot but a philosophical challenge to the series’ central premise.
This is exactly the kind of middle-book work that series fiction needs: not merely advancing the plot but complicating the argument.
David’s Growth
David in Firefight is recognizably the same obsessive data-collector from Steelheart, but he has been changed by having his obsession rewarded and by leading actual operations rather than simply studying them. The David who exists at the end of this book — who has been to a second city, who has confronted his assumptions about Epics, who has experienced real loss — is ready for the series-ending confrontation in a way the David from book one wasn’t.
Sanderson manages the character development without losing the voice that made David appealing, which is the most technically difficult thing to do in a YA series protagonist.
Our rating: 4.3/5 — A strong middle entry that uses its new setting and deepened philosophy to complicate the series’ central premise rather than simply extending it.
Ready to Read Firefight?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: