Editors Reads Verdict
Moreno-Garcia's gothic horror novel is a lush, atmospheric triumph that grafts classic English manor house dread onto Mexican history and landscape — the colonial horror at its core gives the familiar genre machinery real ideological bite.
What We Loved
- The colonial horror subtext gives the gothic elements genuine thematic weight
- Noemí is an uncommonly vivid and capable gothic heroine
- 1950s Mexico City and rural Hidalgo are rendered with sensory precision
- The pacing builds dread expertly without telegraphing its revelations
Minor Drawbacks
- The horror mechanics in the final act may frustrate readers who prefer psychological ambiguity
- Some secondary characters are drawn thinly
- The romance subplot is underdeveloped
Key Takeaways
- → Gothic horror is most effective when its monsters embody real historical violence
- → The manor house tradition carries specific colonial implications worth interrogating
- → Gaslighting is the domestic iteration of broader social control mechanisms
- → Women's knowledge and judgment are systematically discredited as a form of control
- → Horror rooted in specific historical crimes achieves moral clarity
| Author | Silvia Moreno-Garcia |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Del Rey |
| Pages | 320 |
| Published | June 30, 2020 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Gothic Fiction, Historical Fiction, Horror |
| Difficulty | Intermediate |
| Best For | Readers of gothic and literary horror, fans of historical fiction set outside Europe, and readers interested in horror that engages with colonialism and race. |
A Haunting With Deep Roots
Noemí Taboada is not the typical gothic heroine. She is not naive, not passive, not easily frightened. She is a Mexico City socialite — stylish, educated, impatient with condescension — who arrives at High Place, the Doyle family’s crumbling Hidalgo estate, because her cousin Catalina has sent a disturbing letter suggesting she is being poisoned. Noemí intends to find out why.
Silvia Moreno-Garcia’s 2020 novel arrived during the pandemic and became a word-of-mouth phenomenon. Its pitch — Gothic horror in 1950s Mexico, with echoes of Rebecca and Du Maurier’s femme gothique tradition — attracted readers who wanted the pleasures of classic genre fiction with something more intellectually ambitious underneath.
Colonial Horror as Core
What distinguishes Mexican Gothic from its Anglo precursors is its explicit engagement with colonial violence. The Doyle family are English mine owners whose wealth in Mexico was extracted from indigenous labor under conditions that amounted to slavery. Their estate, High Place, is literally built on that history — the house’s corruption and the horror it harbors are extensions of the violence that created it.
This isn’t allegory operating at remove; Moreno-Garcia makes the connection explicit. The horror of High Place is colonial horror, and the family that sustains it is monstrous precisely because they have made their violence systematic and self-perpetuating.
Noemí Against the House
The novel’s central relationship — between Noemí’s fierce, skeptical intelligence and the house’s systematic effort to undermine it — is the source of its most effective dread. The Doyle family’s gaslighting is both psychologically realistic and literally supernatural, and Moreno-Garcia keeps the ambiguity intact long enough to make the revelation satisfying.
Noemí as protagonist is a genuine contribution to the gothic tradition. She is not saved by her own innocence or by a male protector; she saves herself through intelligence, stubbornness, and solidarity with her cousin.
Gothic Pleasures Earned
The atmosphere — moldering wallpaper, mushroom-damp corridors, a patriarch who quotes eugenicists at dinner — is executed with tremendous skill. The horror, when it fully materializes, is genuinely disturbing. The colonial critique is woven into the narrative fabric rather than imposed on it.
Our rating: 4.0/5 — A gorgeous, ideologically serious gothic novel that uses the genre’s pleasures to interrogate colonial violence with more honesty than most literary fiction manages.
Ready to Read Mexican Gothic?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: