Editors Reads Verdict
The Iliad is the fountainhead of Western literature: a war epic that is also an anti-war poem, a celebration of heroic glory that is simultaneously a devastating portrait of its costs. No poem has described violent death more accurately or mourned it more sincerely.
What We Loved
- The sustained description of battlefield death is more humanising than any subsequent war writing
- Achilles's transformation — from wrath to grief to something approaching wisdom — is one of literature's great arcs
- Homer gives faces, families, and futures to the men who die — even the enemies
- The final meeting of Achilles and Priam is the most moving scene in ancient literature
Minor Drawbacks
- The catalogue of ships and the extended battle sequences test patience on first reading
- The gods' constant intervention can feel like arbitrary plot manipulation
- The poem rewards context — some knowledge of the Troy story enriches the experience significantly
Key Takeaways
- → War's glory and war's horror are inseparable — the Iliad refuses to sanitise either
- → Heroic culture's demand for personal honour can override every other human value, with catastrophic results
- → Grief is the poem's deepest subject — both Achilles's grief for Patroclus and Priam's for Hector
- → The enemy is as human as you are — Homer consistently insists on the humanity of the Trojans
- → All human glory is temporary — the poem is suffused with awareness of mortality and the fragility of achievement
| Author | Homer |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Penguin Classics |
| Pages | 704 |
| Published | January 1, 750 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Fiction, Classic Literature, Epic Poetry |
| Difficulty | Intermediate |
| Best For | Every serious reader — the Iliad is the source document of Western literature, and engaging with it directly (in a good modern translation) is one of the most rewarding reading experiences available. |
The Poem of Wrath
“Sing, goddess, the anger of Achilles son of Peleus.” The Iliad announces its subject in its first line: not the Trojan War, not the fall of Troy, but menis — the wrath of Achilles, the most dangerous of emotions, the one that sets the entire catastrophe in motion and shapes its consequences.
Homer’s poem is set in the final weeks of the ten-year siege of Troy, focusing not on the war’s beginning or end but on its psychological core: the moment when the Greek champion Achilles, humiliated by the commander Agamemnon’s seizure of his war-prize, withdraws from battle and refuses to fight. The Greeks suffer defeat after defeat without him. Achilles watches. His closest companion Patroclus, unable to endure the Greeks’ suffering, borrows Achilles’s armour and leads a counterattack — and is killed by Hector, Troy’s greatest champion.
This death — of the person Achilles loves most — transforms the poem. Achilles’s wrath against Agamemnon becomes wrath against Hector, wrath against death itself, wrath against a world in which glory is purchased by mortality. His return to battle is not triumphant but terrible: a man not merely fighting but destroying, the rage of grief given a sword.
The Humanity of Death
What makes the Iliad unique in the literature of war is Homer’s refusal to separate heroic glory from its cost. When a warrior dies in the Iliad, Homer often pauses to give us his name, his home, his father, his life before the war — the specific individual who is now gone. This technique — the obituary embedded in the killing — is not sentimental but insistently humanising: every death is a person, not a statistic.
Homer performs this humanisation for Trojans and Greeks equally. Hector, Troy’s defender, is in many ways the poem’s most sympathetic figure: a man who does not want the war, who loves his wife and infant son, who knows the city will fall and fights anyway out of duty and honour. His farewell to his wife Andromache and his small son — who is frightened by Hector’s plumed helmet and makes his father laugh before he leaves — is one of the most tender passages in ancient literature.
Achilles and Priam: The Poem’s Heart
The poem reaches its emotional culmination in Book 24, when Priam, King of Troy, enters Achilles’s camp at night to beg for his son Hector’s body. The scene is almost unbearably moving: an old king humbling himself before the man who killed his finest son, and Achilles — who has been presented for much of the poem as something barely human in his wrath — being recalled to humanity by the sight of a father’s grief.
They weep together. Achilles for Patroclus; Priam for Hector. Two enemies, joined by grief, briefly outside the war that is consuming them both.
Our rating: 4.7/5 — The source of Western literature and the most honest account of war ever written — simultaneously a celebration and an elegy.
Ready to Read The Iliad?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: