Editors Reads Verdict
Matt Haig's most commercially successful novel is a warm, philosophically accessible meditation on regret, possibility, and the strange calculus by which we measure a life worth living. It is unabashedly hopeful in ways that earn rather than sentimentalize that hope.
What We Loved
- The central metaphor is elegant, immediately comprehensible, and emotionally resonant
- Nora's depression is depicted with clinical accuracy and genuine compassion
- The book of regrets device generates both plot and philosophical substance
- Accessible philosophical content that doesn't condescend to non-specialist readers
Minor Drawbacks
- Some parallel-life sequences feel more sketched than fully realized
- The emotional resolution arrives somewhat quickly in the final act
- Readers seeking darker or more ambiguous fiction may find the tone too optimistic
- The prose prioritizes accessibility over literary distinction
Key Takeaways
- → Regret is not evidence that other choices would have brought happiness
- → Depression distorts our assessment of the value of our own lives
- → The version of yourself in any given life is shaped by that life's constraints
- → Connection — to people, to purpose, to place — is what makes life feel worth living
- → It is possible to choose life even when it requires active, sustained effort
| Author | Matt Haig |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Viking |
| Pages | 304 |
| Published | September 29, 2020 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Literary Fiction, Philosophical Fiction, Speculative Fiction |
| Difficulty | Beginner |
| Best For | Readers who enjoy philosophically engaged fiction with emotional warmth, particularly those who have experienced depression or grief. |
Between Life and Every Possible Life
Matt Haig has been candid about his own experiences with depression and suicidal ideation, and that autobiography lends The Midnight Library a moral authority that might otherwise be harder to achieve. The novel is not autobiography, but it is clearly written by someone who understands what it feels like to believe, with total conviction, that your existence is a net negative in the world.
Nora Seed is having the worst day of a life she has concluded is worthless when she finds herself in the Midnight Library — an infinite institution between life and death, presided over by her childhood librarian, Mrs. Elm. Each book represents a life Nora could have lived had she made different choices. She can enter any of them, try that life, and continue or return.
The Regret Mechanism
The Book of Regrets that catalogs Nora’s grievances with her own choices is the novel’s most clever structural device. It is also its most philosophically pointed element: as Nora tries different lives, she discovers that the things she regretted not doing are often more complicated in execution than they were in imagination. The Olympics career she could have had required sacrifices she also would have regretted. The relationship she could have preserved was more damaged than her memory admitted. Haig uses the premise to interrogate the regret mechanism itself rather than simply celebrating alternate possibilities.
Depression Depicted with Care
Haig’s portrayal of Nora’s depression avoids both melodrama and minimization. She is not dramatically tortured; she is quietly, exhaustedly certain that no one would meaningfully miss her. The dissociation, the sense of being a burden, the way small failures feel like cosmic verdicts — these are recognizable to readers who have been there, and educational to those who haven’t.
The Optimism Question
The Midnight Library is openly hopeful, and some literary readers have questioned whether this hope is earned or merely asserted. The counterargument is that Haig earns it through specificity — Nora doesn’t discover an obvious, pre-waiting perfect life. She discovers that life’s value is not a matter of optimal circumstance.
Our rating: 4.2/5 — A warm, philosophically intelligent novel that treats depression seriously while making a genuine case for the value of staying.
Ready to Read The Midnight Library?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: