Editors Reads Verdict
The first modern novel and still one of its greatest — Cervantes's comic masterpiece is also a profound meditation on the relationship between fiction and reality, madness and vision, idealism and practicality. Don Quixote is the ancestor of every novel written since.
What We Loved
- The windmill episode has become a universal symbol — the whole novel lives in its imagination
- The Quixote-Sancho relationship is one of literature's great comedic-philosophical duos
- Part II, where characters who have read Part I encounter the real Don Quixote, is a metafictional marvel
- Cervantes's humour is generous rather than cruel — he loves his characters' absurdities
Minor Drawbacks
- At over 1000 pages, the episodic structure can become repetitive
- The inserted tales (the Captive's narrative, etc.) interrupt the main story's flow
- Some of the humour depends on chivalric romance conventions that require historical context
Key Takeaways
- → The novel form itself was born as a critique of fiction — Cervantes parodies romance to create something more honest
- → Idealism and reality are both necessary — Quixote without Sancho is madness; Sancho without Quixote is mere appetite
- → The relationship between author, text, and reader is never straightforward — Part II makes this explicit
- → A life dedicated to a fiction can be more genuinely heroic than a life of mere fact
- → Madness and vision are not easily distinguishable — the mad see things the sane miss
| Author | Miguel de Cervantes |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Penguin Classics |
| Pages | 1072 |
| Published | January 16, 1605 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Fiction, Classic Literature, Satire |
| Difficulty | Intermediate |
| Best For | Readers who want to understand where the novel came from — and those who enjoy philosophical comedy of the highest order. Reading in a good modern translation is strongly recommended. |
The First Novel and the Last
Published in two parts in 1605 and 1615, Don Quixote is simultaneously the first modern novel and a book that has never been surpassed in the range of what it attempts. Cervantes, writing in a Spain that was beginning its long imperial decline, invented a new literary form by satirising an older one: the chivalric romance. His satirical gesture — an aging Spanish hidalgo so addicted to novels of chivalry that he loses his mind and decides to become a knight-errant — opened up a space that four centuries of novelists have inhabited.
Alonso Quijano, who renames himself Don Quixote of La Mancha, is simultaneously ridiculous and heroic. He tilts at windmills believing them giants. He terrorises travellers he believes to be villains. He pursues a peasant girl he has imagined into a noblewoman named Dulcinea del Toboso. He suffers beatings, humiliations, and every kind of physical disaster. And he endures it all with a dignity that is genuinely magnificent, because within the fiction he inhabits, his actions are entirely coherent and genuinely noble.
Sancho Panza: The Perfect Counter-Weight
Don Quixote’s squire Sancho Panza is the novel’s other great creation: a fat, practical, thoroughly earthbound peasant who attaches himself to his master for promised rewards and gradually — against his better judgement, against all evidence — becomes infected with something like his master’s vision. Sancho believes and doesn’t believe simultaneously, and this double consciousness makes him the most modern character in a four-century-old book.
The Quixote-Sancho relationship is the template for every odd-couple pairing in literature, but also something more: a philosophical dialogue about the relationship between imagination and reality, conducted through slapstick. Sancho’s proverbs, his appetite, his peasant wisdom — these are not just comic counterpoint but Cervantes’s way of insisting that reality has its own claims on a life lived in fiction.
Part II: The Metafictional Masterpiece
The publication of a spurious Part II by a writer using the pseudonym Alonso Fernández de Avellaneda between Cervantes’s two volumes gave him the most extraordinary narrative opportunity: in the real Part II, characters have read Part I. They know who Don Quixote is. They stage situations for him. The knight moves through a world that has been shaped by his fictional existence in a way that anticipates postmodernism by three and a half centuries.
The Ending’s Desolation
When Don Quixote recovers his sanity on his deathbed — when Alonso Quijano returns from the knight’s adventure — the moment is devastating rather than redemptive. The recovery of reason is also the loss of everything that made his life significant.
Our rating: 4.5/5 — The founding text of the Western novel, and still one of its supreme achievements.
Ready to Read Don Quixote?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: