Editors Reads Verdict
Towles delivers another meticulously crafted period piece with a cast of unforgettable characters, using an America-in-motion story to meditate on fate, free will, and the stories we tell ourselves about who we are.
What We Loved
- Beautifully constructed with a distinctive rotating-perspective structure
- Duchess is one of the most vivid characters in recent American fiction
- Period detail of 1954 America is immersive and lovingly rendered
- Thematically rich meditation on fate, choice, and narrative
Minor Drawbacks
- The ending divides readers sharply — some find it devastating, others unsatisfying
- At 592 pages, the pacing occasionally slackens
- Eight-year-old Billy's voice sometimes strains credibility
Key Takeaways
- → The stories we use to organize our lives can trap us as surely as prison bars
- → Free will and predetermination are not opposites but accomplices
- → Loyalty and love are not the same as enabling
- → America's myth of reinvention is available to some and withheld from others
- → Characters who cannot rewrite their own stories are doomed to repeat them
| Author | Amor Towles |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Viking |
| Pages | 592 |
| Published | October 5, 2021 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Literary Fiction, Historical Fiction |
| Difficulty | Intermediate |
| Best For | Literary fiction readers; fans of A Gentleman in Moscow; anyone drawn to mid-century American settings. |
A Journey Interrupted
June 1954: Emmett Watson comes home to Nebraska after eighteen months at a juvenile work farm, having killed a boy in a fight he didn’t start. His plan is simple — sell the family farm, collect his eight-year-old brother Billy, and drive to California to start fresh. But two friends from the work farm have stowed away in the trunk of the warden’s car, and one of them, the incandescent, unreliable, lovable Duchess, has other ideas. Within hours, the brothers’ journey west has been redirected to New York.
The Picaresque Structure
Towles tells his story in short chapters that rotate perspective among four primary characters: Emmett, the earnest and burdened older brother; Billy, who navigates the world through the lens of hero stories and a book of notable American figures; Duchess, whose charisma conceals a terrifying commitment to a personal code of reciprocity; and Woolly, Duchess’s gentle, damaged friend who lives entirely inside his own inner world. The structure creates dramatic irony — we watch characters act on information others lack — while building to convergences that feel both surprising and inevitable.
Duchess: An American Archetype
The novel’s great achievement is Duchess, a figure simultaneously infuriating and irresistible. His personal code — every good turn deserves a good turn, every wrong deserves settling — is both his defining quality and his fatal flaw. Towles uses Duchess to examine the American mythos of the self-made man, the romantic outlaw, the person who lives outside society’s rules by a code purer and simpler than society’s. Duchess believes he is the hero of a Western. The novel gently, devastatingly disagrees.
Fate and Free Will
Beneath the picaresque adventure, “The Lincoln Highway” is a philosophical novel about whether people can change direction or whether character is destiny. Billy’s faith in the hero’s journey as a map for real life becomes the book’s structuring metaphor. The question Towles poses — can we write a different story for ourselves, or does our character always reassert itself? — receives an answer in the final pages that readers will debate for a long time.
Our rating: 4.3/5 — A brilliantly constructed American journey with characters who will live in readers’ minds long after the last page.
Ready to Read The Lincoln Highway?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: