Editors Reads Verdict
Grann's adventure-mystery about one of exploration history's most enduring disappearances is propulsive, carefully researched, and self-aware about the obsessive psychology that drives men into the Amazon — and the western assumptions that have always distorted our view of it.
What We Loved
- The dual narrative — Fawcett's expeditions and Grann's investigation — interweaves expertly
- Grann's self-deprecating voice is engaging without undermining the seriousness
- The archaeological science around pre-Columbian Amazon civilization is fascinating
- The book interrogates the colonial assumptions embedded in exploration mythology
Minor Drawbacks
- The archaeological details occasionally crowd out the human drama
- Fawcett himself remains somewhat opaque despite extensive documentation
- The resolution, while interesting, may feel anticlimactic after 300 pages of buildup
Key Takeaways
- → Western ideas of lost civilizations are themselves a form of colonial fantasy
- → The Amazon was home to sophisticated pre-Columbian urban societies
- → Obsession rarely distinguishes between the object and the pursuit
- → Dozens of rescue expeditions seeking Fawcett vanished trying to find him
- → New archaeological methods are overturning assumptions about Amazonian prehistory
| Author | David Grann |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Doubleday |
| Pages | 339 |
| Published | February 24, 2009 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Narrative Nonfiction, Adventure, History |
| Difficulty | Beginner |
| Best For | Adventure and exploration history readers, archaeology enthusiasts, and fans of Grann's narrative style who want a mystery embedded in genuine historical stakes. |
The Explorer Who Wouldn’t Come Back
Percy Fawcett was one of the last great Edwardian explorers — a British Army officer who mapped unmapped regions of the Amazon for the Royal Geographical Society and became convinced, based on indigenous accounts and colonial documents, that an ancient civilization of unprecedented sophistication lay hidden somewhere in the Mato Grosso of Brazil. He called it Z.
In 1925, he set out to find it with his son Jack and Jack’s friend Raleigh Rimell. None of them were ever seen again. At least thirteen subsequent expeditions were sent to find them. Several of those expeditions also disappeared.
David Grann’s account of Fawcett’s obsession and his own investigation into the disappearance is one of adventure nonfiction’s most satisfying structures: the historical narrative drives forward while the present-day investigative narrative closes in from behind, and both strands arrive at a conclusion that reframes the entire project.
The Amazon We Didn’t Know
The book’s most lasting contribution may be its engagement with the science of pre-Columbian Amazonian civilization. For decades, archaeologists assumed the Amazon basin couldn’t have supported large settled populations — the soil is too poor, the forest too demanding. Recent discoveries, including terra preta (engineered black earth) and the traces of what appear to have been extensive urban networks, suggest otherwise.
Fawcett may have been chasing a real thing — not the golden city of European fantasy, but the traces of sophisticated pre-Columbian civilization systematically destroyed by disease and conquest. That realization gives the book a melancholy dimension it earns.
Grann as Self-Aware Investigator
One of The Lost City of Z’s pleasures is Grann’s comic self-awareness about his own inadequacy as an explorer. He is not Fawcett: he is out of shape, prone to insect anxiety, and entirely aware that his Amazon trip is professionally necessary but personally inadvisable. That honesty prevents the book from romanticizing the exploration tradition it documents.
The Western Gaze Interrogated
The book’s finest intellectual move is questioning why westerners felt entitled to “discover” civilizations that had always been known to the people who lived in them. Fawcett’s Z was always someone else’s home — and the devastation that colonial contact caused means that whatever he found, he may have ultimately destroyed it.
Our rating: 4.3/5 — A compulsive adventure-mystery that combines Fawcett’s gripping story with a serious reconsideration of what exploration mythology has always gotten wrong about the Amazon.
Ready to Read The Lost City of Z?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: