The Likeness — Dublin Murder Squad #2

The Body with Your Face

When a young woman is found stabbed in an abandoned cottage outside Dublin, the case would be routine — except that the victim is carrying the ID of Alexandra Madison, an alias Detective Cassie Maddox used years earlier during an undercover operation. More unsettling still: the dead woman looks exactly like Cassie. So begins The Likeness, Tana French’s second Dublin Murder Squad novel, which takes the Gothic premise of a detective stepping into a dead woman’s life and elevates it into one of the most atmospheric crime novels of the century so far.

Cassie goes undercover at Whitethorn House, a crumbling Georgian property where the victim had lived as part of a close-knit group of five PhD students. Her goal is to pose as Lexie Madison, alive and recovering from an attack, and discover who among her housemates wanted her dead. What she finds instead is something she hadn’t anticipated: she wants to stay.

Whitethorn House as Character

The novel’s real subject is belonging. French constructs Whitethorn House and its inhabitants — Daniel, Abby, Justin, Rafe — as a kind of secular monastery, a deliberate retreat from the world’s demands. They have created their own economy, their own customs, their own language. From the outside this looks like a cult; from the inside it feels like the only place in the world where the noise of modern life has been turned off.

French is extraordinary at rendering the seductiveness of this arrangement. Cassie begins to feel what Lexie felt — that this house, these people, this life are worth protecting at almost any cost. The narrative tension comes not just from the question of who killed Lexie, but from whether Cassie can complete her assignment before she loses herself in the role entirely. It is a mystery about the instability of identity as much as about a murder.

French’s Literary Ambition

What separates French from her crime fiction contemporaries is prose that can bear the weight of what she is attempting. Descriptions of the house, the fields, the seasons moving through the Irish countryside carry genuine literary force. The dialogue among the housemates — a five-way conversation that Cassie must enter as though she has always been part of it — crackles with the specific energy of people who have built a private world together.

The novel has been compared to Donna Tartt’s The Secret History, and the comparison is apt: both books are about a closed intellectual community, a killing that emerges from within, and a narrator seduced by belonging. But French’s procedural architecture and the specificity of Cassie’s emotional situation give The Likeness its own distinct pressure.

A Worthy Successor

The Likeness consolidates French’s reputation as the most important crime writer working in English. It takes genuine risks — the premise strains credulity, the pacing is deliberately unhurried — and those risks pay off. The ending is not triumphant; it is sad and true and earns every quiet page that precedes it.

Our rating: 4.4/5

Reading Guides

• Books Like Tana French: 12 Literary Crime Novels for Dublin Murder Squad Fans
• Books Like The Silence of the Lambs: 12 Psychological Thrillers to Read Next
• Tana French Books in Order: Complete Dublin Murder Squad Reading Guide (2026)
• 22 Best Mystery Books of All Time: Essential Reads From Christie to Flynn (2026)

The Donna Tartt Comparison

The comparison to The Secret History — made by many reviewers of The Likeness — is apt but illuminating in its limits. Both novels concern a closed intellectual community in which a murder has been committed, and both deploy a narrator who is partly an insider and partly an observer. But where Tartt’s Richard Papen is seduced by beauty and privilege, French’s Cassie Maddox is seduced by belonging — by the specific quality of a life in which the usual demands of the contemporary world have been refused, and in which five people have created something genuinely their own. The Whitethorn House community is not glamorous in Tartt’s terms; it is provincial, slightly eccentric, and built around the ordinary pleasures of cooking communal meals, renovating a house, and maintaining a shared commitment to each other that the outside world would find impossible to sustain. That this modest arrangement should be so seductive to Cassie is French’s most penetrating observation: the hunger for belonging is not diminished by the modesty of the arrangement that satisfies it.

Cassie Maddox’s Arc Across Two Novels

Cassie Maddox is introduced in In the Woods as Rob Ryan’s partner and the novel’s moral centre — the person who sees clearly what Rob cannot, whose loyalty to him is both her strength and her vulnerability. Her re-emergence as the protagonist of The Likeness allows French to explore what happened to Cassie after the events of the first novel — not directly, but through the specific shape of her damage, the way she has been changed by what Rob’s choices cost her. Reading the two novels in sequence gives The Likeness an additional layer: Cassie going undercover as a dead woman is also Cassie attempting to inhabit a life that is not contaminated by what she has lived through. The seduction of Whitethorn House is partly the seduction of a fresh start, of being, for a few weeks, someone else entirely.

The Gothic Tradition

The Likeness sits comfortably in the tradition of Gothic fiction about enclosed houses and the secrets they contain — a tradition that runs from Wuthering Heights through Rebecca and Daphne du Maurier’s Cornish novels, and that French absorbs and transforms for her contemporary Irish setting. Whitethorn House is a real Gothic house: crumbling, beautiful, too large for its occupants, full of history that the current inhabitants have not made and do not fully understand. The discovery that the house has a past that its tenants have been living inside without knowing it is the novel’s Gothic spine, and French handles the revelation — when it comes — with the careful architecture of someone who has understood what makes the tradition work and what makes it creak.