Editors Reads Verdict
Atwood's long-awaited sequel won the Booker Prize alongside Bernardine Evaristo's Girl, Woman, Other, and it earns the recognition — a formally inventive, politically sharp continuation that centers Aunt Lydia as its most compelling voice and delivers the satisfying context that the original deliberately withheld.
What We Loved
- Aunt Lydia's testimony is the most riveting piece of writing Atwood has produced in years
- The three-narrator structure provides genuine multiple perspectives on Gilead
- Addresses the structural gaps that readers of the first novel spent decades speculating about
- The political analysis of how totalitarian systems decay from within is sophisticated
Minor Drawbacks
- The younger narrators (Agnes, Nicole) are less distinctive than Lydia's voice
- The thriller elements are more prominent and less nuanced than the first novel's tone
- Readers who prefer ambiguity may find this more resolved than the original
- The Hulu series having advanced the story creates some narrative complications
Key Takeaways
- → Those who built oppressive systems possess unique knowledge of their vulnerabilities
- → Institutional power corrupts even those who believed they were merely using it tactically
- → Information hoarded strategically becomes the most powerful weapon in a surveillance state
- → Identity built entirely around ideology is catastrophically fragile when that ideology fails
- → Systems that depend on enforced ignorance are vulnerable to education
| Author | Margaret Atwood |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Nan A. Talese |
| Pages | 419 |
| Published | September 10, 2019 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Dystopian Fiction, Literary Fiction, Political Fiction |
| Difficulty | Intermediate |
| Best For | Readers of The Handmaid's Tale who want resolution and context, and who are interested in how authoritarian systems collapse from internal corruption. |
Thirty-Four Years Later
Margaret Atwood resisted writing a sequel to The Handmaid’s Tale for over three decades. The original’s power derived in part from its refusal to resolve — Offred’s fate is deliberately left open, Gilead’s eventual end is implied by the Historical Notes’ future-tense framing, but nothing is confirmed. The Testaments, published in 2019 as the Hulu series expanded what television audiences knew of Gilead, provides answers Atwood had long declined to give.
The result is formally different from its predecessor: where The Handmaid’s Tale is a single voice excavating personal memory under extraordinary constraint, The Testaments uses three testimonies to approach the same world from radically different angles. Nicole (the baby from the first novel, grown up in Canada), Agnes (a Commander’s daughter in Gilead), and Aunt Lydia constitute the novel’s three pillars.
Aunt Lydia’s Confession
The finest achievement in The Testaments is Aunt Lydia’s testimony, titled “The Ardua Hall Holograph.” Atwood finally gives us the origin story of one of the first novel’s most disturbing figures — the woman who built the system of Handmaid indoctrination — and her account of how she survived Gilead’s founding terror and calculated her way into a position of power is compelling beyond anything else in the book.
What makes Aunt Lydia’s sections so effective is that Atwood refuses to make her simply a villain or simply a hero. She made terrible choices to preserve herself, then made more terrible choices to preserve her power, and now makes one consequential choice to use that power toward Gilead’s undoing. All three decisions are comprehensible, none is fully redeemable, and together they constitute a sophisticated analysis of what participation in oppressive systems actually involves.
The Successor Generation
Agnes and Nicole represent Gilead’s youth: one raised inside its ideology, one raised outside it. Their experiences as agents of change — however involuntary — provide the thriller momentum the novel requires. They are less distinctive than Lydia but serve their structural function.
How Systems Fall
The Testaments’ most original contribution to the Grishaverse conversation is its analysis of how totalitarian systems collapse not through external pressure primarily but through the decay of internal loyalty. The Aunts’ institutional power over information, the Commanders’ competing interests, the system’s fundamental contradictions — these are the cracks through which Gilead eventually fails.
Our rating: 4.2/5 — A worthy sequel that earns the Booker Prize on the strength of Aunt Lydia’s testimony alone, while providing the resolution devoted readers had long sought.
Ready to Read The Testaments?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: