Editors Reads Verdict
Hemingway's first novel defined the Lost Generation's aesthetic: a prose of elegant surfaces and suppressed depths, populated by people whose war wounds — physical and psychological — have made genuine feeling both more necessary and less possible. The fiesta at Pamplona is American modernism at its most accomplished.
What We Loved
- The Paris and Pamplona sections establish atmosphere with seemingly effortless economy
- The iceberg principle is at its most effective — what is unsaid about Jake's wound carries enormous weight
- The corrida sequences capture the specific beauty of bullfighting as art
- The novel invented the expatriate aesthetic that shaped a generation of American writers
Minor Drawbacks
- The anti-Semitism in the portrayal of Robert Cohn is a genuine problem, not merely a product of its era
- Brett Ashley, while fascinating, is denied the interiority given to the male characters
- The novel's emotional flatness, while intentional, can feel like a defence against feeling
Key Takeaways
- → The Lost Generation's rootlessness is not personal failure but the result of civilisational destruction
- → Jake's wound — his inability to consummate love — externalises the generation's general condition
- → Authentic experience (the fiesta, the fishing, the bullfight) is possible, but it exists within a context of loss
- → The code hero — the bullfighter, the man who does his work well regardless of circumstances — is Hemingway's ideal
- → Money and mobility create freedom and also rootlessness — the expatriate lifestyle is simultaneously liberation and exile
| Author | Ernest Hemingway |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Scribner |
| Pages | 251 |
| Published | October 22, 1926 |
| Language | English |
| Genre | Fiction, Classic Literature, Modernism |
| Difficulty | Beginner |
| Best For | Readers interested in American modernism and the 1920s Paris scene — and those who want to understand the literary generation shaped by World War I and its aftermath. |
The Lost Generation Finds Its Voice
Ernest Hemingway’s first novel, published in 1926, announced a new voice in American fiction and named a generation. Gertrude Stein had told him that young men who had served in the war were “a lost generation” — directionless, unable to reconnect with the civilian values they had left behind — and Hemingway used the phrase as an epigraph and the idea as the novel’s subject.
Jake Barnes is an American journalist in Paris, a veteran whose war wound has left him sexually incapable. He is in love with Brett Ashley, a beautiful, troubled Englishwoman who loves him in return and cannot remain faithful to anyone. Around them moves a circle of expatriates — Robert Cohn, Bill Gorton, Mike Campbell — who drink heavily, travel restlessly, and maintain surfaces of wit and irony over feelings they cannot express.
Paris: The City as Emotional Weather
The Paris of The Sun Also Rises is rendered in a series of short, precisely observed scenes — bars, restaurants, the rue de Rivoli, the Left Bank cafés where Hemingway himself spent his early years. The city is simultaneously beautiful and empty: a place to be rather than a place to become. Jake’s routine is meticulous and slightly compulsive, the precision of a man keeping darkness at bay through habit.
The novel’s emotional key is established in an early scene where Jake, alone in his apartment, thinks about Brett and cries. It is over immediately. He does not let himself dwell. This compression — the acknowledgement and the suppression of feeling in a single paragraph — is Hemingway’s method applied to character.
Pamplona: The Fiesta as Revelation
The novel’s great section is the fiesta at Pamplona: the running of the bulls, the corrida, the nights of drinking and dancing that briefly make the characters feel genuinely alive. Hemingway had been to Pamplona himself and brought a careful observer’s precision to the bullfighting sequences — the specific movements of specific matadors, the quality of different bulls, the relationship between skill and danger.
The bullfighter Pedro Romero — brave, skilled, utterly unself-conscious in his art — is the novel’s positive moral figure: someone who does his work with absolute commitment regardless of the audience, the commentary, or the cost. He is, implicitly, who Jake wants to be and cannot.
Robert Cohn’s Function
The novel’s treatment of Robert Cohn — the Jewish Princeton boxer who is explicitly excluded from the code values the other characters share — has been extensively criticised as anti-Semitic, and the criticism is warranted. Cohn functions as a foil whose romanticism and sentimentality are contrasted with the other characters’ ironic detachment, and his Jewishness is presented as connected to these failings in ways that reflect Hemingway’s prejudice.
Our rating: 4.4/5 — The novel that defined American expatriate modernism — formally brilliant and ethically compromised in exactly the way its generation was.
Ready to Read The Sun Also Rises?
Check the current price on Amazon.
Check Price on Amazon (paid link)Prices and availability are subject to change. See Amazon for current price.
Review last updated: